Democracy does not extinguish conflict: it organises it. Starting from two opposing demonstrations in Glasgow, protected by the police in the same public space, this text revisits thinking about conflict from Hobbes to Chantal Mouffe and argues that turning the enemy into an adversary is the heart of democracy. It ends on a question: do our democratic instruments still protect the sovereignty of the people?
Democracy is not the absence or the extinction of conflict. On the contrary, it is the capacity to channel and structure violence within regulated and protected spaces, so that political contradictions can be expressed without turning into civil war.
Yesterday, Saturday, two opposing movements occupied the same public and political space in the streets of Glasgow. On one side, the anti-immigration far right, part of a worrying trend of radicalisation and of the rise of the British populist right. A similar movement in London brought together hundreds of thousands of demonstrators, with Éric Zemmour, the French far-right essayist and politician who founded the Reconquête party, present among them, chanting slogans such as: “France for the French, England for the English.” In Glasgow, a city with a strong left-wing tradition and one of the highest immigration rates in the United Kingdom, trade unions and progressive movements organised a counter-mobilisation. In the same space, the far right found itself in the minority. The police, for their part, were deployed to protect residents, to protect the demonstrators from one another, but above all to guarantee the safety of the democratic space of confrontation.
The existence of conflict in public space, protected by public force, is therefore the very foundation of democracy. It is a sign of vitality, not of weakness. It is in this sense that I share the critical reflection of Chantal Mouffe, the Belgian political philosopher and theorist of “agonistic” democracy: “Democracy requires transforming the enemy into an adversary.” Democracy lives on conflicts governed by shared rules, and it transforms destructive antagonism into productive agonism. It is not a fixed state but a permanent process, in which we must constantly ask how to protect the power of all against its capture by a minority.
From the seventeenth to the twenty-first century, political thought has changed in its relationship to conflict. For Thomas Hobbes, the English philosopher and author of Leviathan (1651), conflict is natural and destructive; it must be suppressed by a strong sovereign. For Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the Genevan philosopher and author of The Social Contract (1762), it arises from particular interests and must be overcome by the unity of the general will. By contrast, Karl Marx, the German philosopher and economist, sees class struggle as the true engine of history, and Carl Schmitt, the German jurist and theorist of the political, makes the friend/enemy conflict the very essence of politics. More recently, the French philosopher Claude Lefort and Chantal Mouffe have restored conflict to the heart of democracy: the former speaks of “power as an empty place”, always open to contest; the latter insists on the need to transform antagonism (an enemy to be destroyed) into agonism (a legitimate adversary). Contemporary democracy, then, does not eliminate conflict: it institutionalises it as a vital principle of how it works.
For a decade, democracy has been in retreat in many parts of the world. We speak of a “crisis”, even though the historical trend since 1789 remains one of gradual democratisation. This crisis should push us to reflect not only on the idea of democracy – creating neutral spaces where the will of all can be exercised – but also on the instruments that set it in motion: elections, parliamentary debate, institutions. The point is not to make these instruments sacred, but to ask whether they are truly democratic, whether they still embody and protect the sovereignty of the people. It is in this gap, between the idea of democracy and its means, that there is an intellectual and political space to fill.
The question
Do our elections, parliaments and institutions still allow us to turn the enemy into an adversary?
Share your position and take the reflection further in the comments below.

Leave a Reply